Having a spare key can save you from stressful lockouts, lost keys, or emergencies. But another question is: who should you trust with a spare key? Choosing the right person is just as important as having the spare key in the first place.

In this article, we’ll go over common and safe choices for giving out a spare key, along with a few things to consider before making that decision. For more background, you can also check out our related articles: Reasons Why to Have a Spare Key and How Many Spare Keys Should I Have?.

1. Family Members

Close family is usually the first choice. Parents, siblings, or adult children are often trusted because they already have access to your home in some capacity. A family member with a spare key can come in handy if you lock yourself out or need someone to check on your place when you’re away.

2. Trusted Friends

If you don’t have family nearby, a long-time friend you trust completely can be another good option. They can hold onto a spare for emergencies or even help feed pets and water plants if you travel. Just make sure it’s someone reliable and responsible.

3. Roommates or Partners

If you live with roommates or share a place with a partner, each person should have their own copy. This avoids the hassle of coordinating who has the key and ensures everyone has access when they need it.

4. Neighbors You Trust

Sometimes, a reliable neighbor can be the best choice. Having a spare with someone who lives next door or in the same building makes it quick and easy to retrieve if you’re locked out. Just be sure your neighbor is someone you know well and trust fully.

5. Property Managers or Landlords

In apartment or rental settings, property managers and landlords usually keep their own copy for emergencies and maintenance. While this isn’t someone you hand a spare to yourself, it’s important to know they may already have access to your unit.

Things to Consider Before Giving Out a Spare

  • Trustworthiness – Only give a key to someone you know will respect your privacy.
  • Accessibility – Pick someone who can get to your place quickly if needed.
  • Responsibility – Choose someone careful enough not to lose the key.

Final Thoughts: Who Should You Give a Spare Key To?

Giving someone a spare key is about more than convenience—it’s about security and peace of mind. Whether you choose family, a friend, or a trusted neighbor, make sure it’s someone reliable.

If you’re considering making spares, remember that multiple copies can be useful for different trusted people. For more guidance, see our articles on Reasons Why to Have a Spare Key and How Many Spare Keys Should I Have?.

Need a spare key or fob made? At MiniFob, we specialize in fast, accurate key and fob duplication—done within minutes and backed by a lifetime guarantee.